Kosher delicatessen · South Main Street · “That Old New York Flavor”

New City Kosher Deli

Over-stuffed corned beef, pastrami and tongue, chicken in the pot, and homemade soup by the pint or the quart. Open from eleven Tuesday through Sunday; closed Mondays.

Call an order in See the menu

Closed Mondays
Under BEHR kosher supervision
Catering
Soup by the pint or the quart
Order combinations by number

Priced off the current takeout menu · a knish instead of the potato is $1

The Menu

To Start

Every price on this page is off their current takeout menu.

Chopped liver
10.95
Stuffed derma
8.95

With gravy.
Stuffed cabbage
10.25
Fried kreplach
9.95

With fried onions.
Potato pierogies
9.95

With fried onions.
Chicken fricassee
12.95
Tongue polynaise
15.50
Potted meatballs
9.95

With gravy.
Buffalo chicken wings
9.95

Homemade soups, to go. Pint 5.25, quart 10.00. An extra matzoh ball or kreplach is 2.00.

Matzoh ball soup
5.25 / 10.00

With noodles.
Chicken soup
5.25 / 10.00

With noodles, rice, kasha or kreplach.
Mushroom barley
5.25 / 10.00
Soup du jour
5.25 / 10.00

Pea, vegetable, lentil or cabbage.

Over Stuffed Sandwiches

On rye, pump, white, wheat or a wrap. Tomato 1.00; roll, bagel or club 1.25; a side of gravy 1.25.

Hot corned beef
15.50
First cut corned beef
16.50
Hot pastrami
15.50
First cut pastrami
16.50
Brisket
15.50
Fresh turkey
14.50
Smoked turkey
14.50
Turkey pastrami
14.50
Roast beef
14.50
Tongue
18.50
Salami
14.50
Bologna
14.50
Meatloaf or turkeyloaf
14.50
Tuna salad
13.50
Chicken salad
13.50
Egg salad
12.50
Chopped liver
14.50
Whitefish salad
15.50
Grilled chicken
14.50
Breaded chicken cutlet
14.50

By the Number

The Smokey Joe combinations. The menu asks you to order them by number. First cut is 1.00 extra per item.

1. Corned beef & pastrami
17.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw.
2. Turkey & chopped liver
17.75

Lettuce, tomato and onion.
3. Pastrami & turkey
17.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw.
4. Tongue & pastrami
19.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw.
5. Brisket & chopped liver
17.75

Lettuce, tomato, onion and sweet pepper.
6. Turkey & salami
17.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw.
7. Roast beef & turkey
17.75

Lettuce and tomato.
8. Corned beef, pastrami & tongue
20.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw. Triple decker.
9. Turkey, pastrami & corned beef
19.75

Russian dressing and cole slaw. Triple decker.
10. Turkey triple decker
19.75

Turkey, pastrami, lettuce, tomato, onion and russian dressing.

And the ones with names of their own.

New City twins
17.75

Corned beef and pastrami on twin dinner rolls, with potato salad.
Sloppy Joe
21.75

Corned beef, pastrami, tongue, roast beef and turkey on rye, russian dressing and cole slaw.
Coney Island
18.50 / 20.50

Corned beef or pastrami on a square knish with hot sauerkraut. Single meat 18.50, combo 20.50.
Hot dog on a bun
3.75

Plain or with sauerkraut. With onions, potato salad or cole slaw 4.50; with chili 5.25.
Nova Scotia on a bagel
19.95

Lettuce, tomato, onion and parve cream cheese.
Nova, whitefish & egg salad on rye
23.75

Triple decker, with lettuce, tomato and onion.

Platters

Hot open sandwiches, served with mashed or french fries.

Roast beef
18.50
Roast turkey
18.50
Corned beef
19.50
Pastrami
19.50
Brisket
19.50

Deli platters serve one to two people, with bread and potato salad. Cold salad platters come with health and potato salad.

Corned beef & pastrami
23.50
Roast beef & turkey
23.50
Pastrami & tongue
25.50
Fresh turkey
23.50

With cranberry sauce.
Combination platter
27.50

Roast beef, turkey, corned beef, pastrami and tongue.
Tuna salad
16.75
Chicken salad
16.75
Egg salad
16.75
Whitefish salad
18.75
Chopped liver
18.75

Eggs & Omelettes

Served with bread or a bagel and french fries or a potato pancake. Egg whites only, 2.00 extra.

Three eggs
12.50

Scrambled or fried.
Salami or bologna
14.50
Corned beef or pastrami
16.50
Western or mushroom
14.50
Mixed deli
16.50
Nova & onions
18.50
Potato pancakes (3)
12.00

With apple sauce.
Challah french toast
11.25

Dinners

A knish instead of the potato is 1.00 extra.

Grilled chicken
21.95

Marinated, with potato and vegetable.
Half roasted or BBQ chicken
21.95

With potato and vegetable.
Chicken in the pot
24.95

With noodles, matzoh ball, kreplach and carrots.
Chicken in the basket
21.95

With french fries and onion rings.
Chicken schnitzel
23.95

Breaded cutlet, with potato and veggie.
Chicken fricassee
23.95

Chicken and meatballs, with vegetable or potato.
Roast turkey
21.95

With stuffing, cranberry sauce, veggie or potato.
Flanken in the pot
26.95

With noodles, matzoh ball, kreplach and carrots.
Corned beef & cabbage
23.95

With boiled potato.
Stuffed cabbage
24.95

Two pieces, with potato or vegetable.
Hungarian beef goulash
23.95

Cubes of beef over noodles.
Potted meatballs
23.95

In gravy, with potato and vegetable.
Brisket of beef
23.95

With a potato pancake and vegetable.
Chopped tenderloin steak
23.95

Topped with onions, with potato and vegetable.
Roumanian tenderloin
30.95

Marinated, topped with fried onions or mushrooms, with potato and vegetable.
Prime rib steak
30.95

With potato and vegetable.
Broiled liver steak
25.95

Topped with fried onions, with potato and vegetable.
Meatloaf or turkeyloaf
21.95

With potato and vegetable.
Poached or broiled salmon
26.95

With potato and vegetable.
New City smorgasbord
25.95

Potted meatballs, stuffed cabbage, Hungarian goulash, derma and noodle pudding. No substitutions.

Sides

French fries
5.50
Sweet potato fries
5.75
Onion rings
5.75
Potato, kasha or mushroom knish
5.50
Square knish
5.00
Vegetable cutlet
5.00
Kasha varnishkes
5.00
Egg barley with mushrooms
5.00
Noodle kugel
5.00
Potato pancake
4.00

With apple sauce.
Mashed potatoes (pint)
6.00
Baked potato
4.75
Roasted potatoes
4.75
Roasted sweet potatoes
4.75
Baked beans
4.75
Israeli salad
5.00
Cucumber salad
5.00
Beet salad
5.00
Potato salad
4.00
Cole slaw
4.00
Macaroni salad
4.00
Small tossed salad
7.00
Roasted veggies
5.00
String beans almondine
5.00

Sweet

Homemade apple strudel
5.00

Seasonal.
Seven-layer cake
5.00
Sweet noodle kugel
5.00
Rugalach, half a pound
7.50
Rugalach, a pound
15.00
Chocolate covered halvah bar
3.75

First cut is $1 extra per item. Jelly rings, fruit slices, non-pareils and vanilla and cherry twists are available.

Under rabbinical supervision · Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg, BEHR Kosher Supervision

The Counter

Kosher

Under rabbinical supervision: Rabbi Dr. Bernhard Rosenberg, BEHR Kosher Supervision. It is printed on the menu itself.

Catering

There is a full catering menu as well as the one above, and a separate menu for Rosh Hashana.

Taking it home

Most of this menu travels. There is a written heating sheet for food taken home, so nobody has to guess at an oven temperature.

Ordering

The combination sandwiches are numbered one to ten and the menu asks you to order by number. Soup goes out by the pint or the quart. Closed Mondays.

Closed Mondays · and there is still a fax number: 845-639-3093

Hours & Directions

Day	Counter
Monday	Closed
Tuesday	11:00 AM – 7:30 PM
Wednesday	11:00 AM – 7:30 PM
Thursday	11:00 AM – 7:30 PM
Friday	11:00 AM – 7:30 PM
Saturday	11:00 AM – 7:30 PM
Sunday	11:00 AM – 7:00 PM

Call

(845) 639-4943

Find us

282 South Main Street
New City, NY 10956

Open in Maps

New City Kosher Deli

The Menu

To Start

Chopped liver

Stuffed derma

Stuffed cabbage

Fried kreplach

Potato pierogies

Chicken fricassee

Tongue polynaise

Potted meatballs

Buffalo chicken wings

Matzoh ball soup

Chicken soup

Mushroom barley

Soup du jour

Over Stuffed Sandwiches

Hot corned beef

First cut corned beef

Hot pastrami

First cut pastrami

Brisket

Fresh turkey

Smoked turkey

Turkey pastrami

Roast beef

Tongue

Salami

Bologna

Meatloaf or turkeyloaf

Tuna salad

Chicken salad

Egg salad

Chopped liver

Whitefish salad

Grilled chicken

Breaded chicken cutlet

By the Number

1. Corned beef & pastrami

2. Turkey & chopped liver

3. Pastrami & turkey

4. Tongue & pastrami

5. Brisket & chopped liver

6. Turkey & salami

7. Roast beef & turkey

8. Corned beef, pastrami & tongue

9. Turkey, pastrami & corned beef

10. Turkey triple decker

New City twins

Sloppy Joe

Coney Island

Hot dog on a bun

Nova Scotia on a bagel

Nova, whitefish & egg salad on rye

Platters

Roast beef

Roast turkey

Corned beef

Pastrami

Brisket

Corned beef & pastrami

Roast beef & turkey

Pastrami & tongue

Fresh turkey

Combination platter

Tuna salad

Chicken salad

Egg salad

Whitefish salad

Chopped liver

Eggs & Omelettes

Three eggs

Salami or bologna

Corned beef or pastrami

Western or mushroom

Mixed deli

Nova & onions

Potato pancakes (3)

Challah french toast

Dinners